Hi Joelle, We are a small academic library and it sounds like our fine structure is similar to yours. We do not charge faculty fines, but once their items roll over to long overdue (lost) their accounts are charged the replacement fee. When long overdue (lost) items are returned, we've noticed that the replacement fee is removed from the account. For that reason, we do not write-off these replacement fees. If we do, when the items are returned the patron account has a positive balance, which creates a whole new set of problems. Our solution is to just handle it on a case-by-case basis. Certain staff can override automatic restrictions on an account with a high balance due because of replacement fees. When the items come back, the fees disappear. Yes, this means our ILL account and some of our faculty often have a balance due on their account. We've accepted that this is just how it is. For faculty, it can also serve as a reminder of sorts that they do have items they need to return. One thing additional you could try is the automatic renewal option. That is in the circulation and fine rules table. It looks like you can set auto renewals to apply to specific item types and patron categories. For example, you could auto renew all books for faculty patrons. This might cut down on the number of items rolling over to long overdue (lost) - or maybe it would just delay the process. We don't use auto renew, but it might be something we try in the future. Feel free to contact me off list if you want to discuss further. Regards, Myka On Fri, Mar 15, 2019 at 10:14 AM Joelle Hannert <jhannert@nmc.edu> wrote:
Hello!
I've been surprised to find that Koha's settings for lost item fees are not as flexible as I'd have hoped. I'd like to be able to apply them based on Patron Category, and also based on item type, but I'm finding that it's an all-or-nothing setting with no granular options. Has anyone found a work-around for this? And, if not, would it be something worth considering as an enhancement? I'm a fairly new Koha user and haven't been involved in the enhancement process yet.
Here are a couple examples specific to our library, in case it helps to have some context:
Patron Categories and lost item fees: We are a college library, and we don't charge fines to faculty/staff. We also have an ILL profile type that we don't charge fines to. We do want to charge students the replacement fees for long-overdue items.
Item types and lost item fees: There are some items that we charge $1/day overdue up to the cost of replacement. For higher-priced items, they hit the long-overdue threshold (28 days) long before the full cost of replacement overdue charge is up (example: $300 for laptops). In our system, at 28 days overdue the lost item replacement charge is put on their account and the daily overdue fine stops accruing. If the item was an overdue laptop that isn't returned until, say, 200 days overdue, the person wouldn't be charged a $200 overdue fine as intended, but a $28 overdue fine, and the $300 replacement fee would be refunded. This is why we'd like granular control, to exclude these item types that accrue overdues up to the cost of replacement from the long overdue process.
Thanks for any insight you can provide!
-- Joelle Hannert Library Technical Services Coordinator Northwestern Michigan College (231) 995-1684 Work days: M, W, Th evening, F _______________________________________________ Koha mailing list http://koha-community.org Koha@lists.katipo.co.nz https://lists.katipo.co.nz/mailman/listinfo/koha
-- Deaconess Myka Kennedy Stephens, MDiv, MSLIS Seminary Librarian and Assistant Professor of Theological Bibliography Lancaster Theological Seminary 555 West James Street Lancaster, PA 17603 717-290-8704 mkstephens@lancasterseminary.edu https://library.lancasterseminary.edu